Social Construction of the “Good Refugee” and the Resistances of Asylum Seekers in Italy between Marginalization and Autonomous Crossing of Urban Spaces
Bd.20,Nr.2(2023)
Street Politics. Space, Identities, Memories, and Conflicts from the Sidewalk
Recent research and studies have undermined the idea that borders are not only a demarcation between an inside and an outside, but a performative space around which unexpected interactions, power relations, economic value, conflicts and new spatialities are produced. Inside and around the structures organized for the reception of asylum seekers, we are witnessing a constantly evolving process of production of new social relations and new micro-spatialities that tend to progressively change the territorial features. This paper, based on observations and materials collected during a long ethnographic study carried out between Padua and Venice, investigates the controversial relations between asylum seekers and such urban spaces and suburbs, with attention given to migrants who relate to the territory just as a point of transit. We analyze the widespread phenomena of segregation these individuals, who have often left the reception system, are subjected to in their daily routine of using public space in certain urban areas. Moreover, through a perspective and a positioning that allowed us to live some protests and phenomena of resistance “from within”, we focus on the ways in which the streets and the squares of the provincial towns and urban centers have presented themselves as “borderscapes”.
bordering; urban segregation; resistance; contested spaces; battleground
Agier, Michel. 2005. “Ordine e disordini dell’umanitario. Dalla vittima al soggetto politico.” Antropologia “Rifugiati” 5: 49–65.
A.s.g.i. 2023. “Il gioco dell’oca del Prefetto di Bologna sui richiedenti asilo.” (https://www.asgi.it/asilo-e-protezione-internazionale/il-gioco-delloca-del-prefetto-di-bologna-sui-richiedenti-asilo/).
Ambrosini, Maurizio, Rosangela Lodigiani, and Sara Zandrini. 1995. L’integrazione subalterna. Peruviani, eritrei e filippini nel mercato del lavoro italiano. Milano: Quaderni ISMU.
Ambrosini, Maurizio. 2021. “The Urban Governance of Asylum as a ‘Battleground’: Policies of Exclusion and Efforts of Inclusion in Italian Towns.” Geografical Review 111(2): 187–205.
Belloni, Milena. 2016. “Learning How to Squat: Cooperation and Conflicts between Refugees and Natives in Rome.” Journal of Refugees Studies 29(4): 506–527.
Belloni, Milena, Enrico Fravega, and Daniela Giudici. 2020. “Fuoridall’accoglienza. Insediamentiinformali di rifugiatitramarginalità e autonomia.” Politiche Sociali 7(2): 225–244.
Brenner Neil. 2009.“What is Critical Urban Theory?” City 13(2): 198–207.
Cancellieri, Adriano and Elena Ostanel. 2015. “The Struggle for Public Space: The Hypervisibility of Migrants in the Italian Urban Landscape.” City 19(4): 499–509.
Campesi, Giuseppe. 2014. “Confinati sulla soglia: Etnografia dei centri per richiedenti asilo in Puglia.” Pp. 37–71 in Passaggi di frontiera: Osservatorio sulla detenzione amministrativa degli immigrati e l’accoglienza dei richiedenti asilo in Puglia, edited by Luigi Pannarale. Pacini Editore.
Caroselli, Serena and Michela Semprebon. 2021.“Seekers and Holders of International Protection in Bozen. Arrival, Transit and Reception within an Internal Border Area.” Pp. 167–188 in Stuck and Exploited. Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Italy between Exclusion, Discrimination and Struggles, edited by Giuliana Sanò, Francesco Della Puppa. Venice: Edizioni Ca’ Foscari Venice University Press.
Colucci, Michele and Stefano Gallo. 2016. Fare spazio. Rapporto 2016 sulle migrazioni interne in Italia. Roma: Donzelli editore.
Cutolo, Armando and Pietro Saitta. 2017. “Collaborare o rigettare? L’arcipelago dell’accoglienza e il “mestiere” dell’antropologo.” Antropologia Pubblica 3(1): 195–207.
Dadusc, Deanna and Pierpaolo Mudu. 2020. “Care without Control: The Humanitarian Industrial Complex and the Criminalisation of Solidarity.” Geopolitics: 1–26.
Darling, Jonathan. 2017. “Forced Migration and the City. Irregularity, Informality and the Politics of Presence.” Progress in Human Geography 41(2): 178–198.
Darling, Jonathan. 2021.“Refugee Urbanism: Seeing Asylum ‘Like a City’.” Urban Geography 42(7): 894–914.
Degli Uberti, Stefano. 2021. “Unveiling Informality through Im/mobility. Conceptual Analysis of Asylum Seekers and Refugees at the Margins of the Reception System in Italy.” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 26(5): 528–551.
De Genova, Nicholas. 2002. “Migrant ‘Illegality’ and Deportability in the Everyday Life.” Annual Review of Antropology 31(1): 419–447.
De Genova, Nicholas, Glenda Garelli, and Martina Tazzioli. 2018. “Autonomy of Asylum? The Autonomy of Migration Undoing the Refugees Crisis Script.” The South Atlantic Quarterly 117(2): 239–265.
Dines, Nick and Enrica Rigo. 2015. “Postcolonial Citizenship between Representation, Borders and the ‘Refugeezation’ of the Workforce: Critical Reflections on Migrant Agricultural Labour in the Italian Mezzogiorno.” Pp. 1–25 in Postcolonial Transition in Europe: Contexts, Practices and Politics, edited by Sandra Ponzanesi, Gianmaria Colpan. London: Rowman and Littlefield.
Di Cecco, Simone. 2019. “Ringraziare per l’ospitalità? Confini dell’accoglienza e nuove frontiere del lavoro migrante nei progetti di volontariato per richiedenti asilo.” Pp. 211–235 in Lungo i confini dell’accoglienza. Migranti e territori tra resistenze e dispositive di controllo, edited by Giulia Fabini, Omid Firouzi Tabar, Francesca Vianello. Rome: Manifestolibri.
Fabini, Giulia. 2023. Polizia e migranti in città. Negoziare il confine nei contesti locali. Rome: Carocci.
Fabini, Giulia and Omid Firouzi Tabar. 2023. “Governing Immobility in the Covid-19 Crisis in Italy: Non-conforming Behaviour of Migrants Confronting the New Old Processes of Othering.” Critical Criminology 31: 307–325.
Fassin, Didier. 2012. Humanitarian Reason. A Moral History of the Present. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Firouzi Tabar, Omid. 2019. “L’accoglienza dei richiedenti asilo tra segregazione e resistenze: un’etnografia a Padova e Provincia.” Pp. 173–210 in Lungo i confini dell’accoglienza. Migranti e territori tra resistenze e dispositive di controllo, edited by Giulia Fabini, Omid Firouzi Tabar, Francesca Vianello. Rome: Manifestolibri.
Firouzi Tabar, Omid. 2020. “Le pareti permeabili dell’accoglienza e la ‘continuità’ dei Decreti Salvini.” Studi Emigrazione 220: 528–546.
Firouzi Tabar, Omid. 2021. “Una ricerca etnografica sul sistema di accoglienza: la ‘giusta distanza’ e i confini tra ricerca e attivismo.” Pp. 66–73 in Ricerca sociale ed emancipazione. Campi, posizionamenti e pratiche, edited by Vincenza Pellegrino, Monica Massari. Genova University Press.
Fontanari, Elena and Maurizio Ambrosini. 2018. “Into the Interstices: Every Day Practices of Refugees and their Supporters in Europe’s Migration ‘Crisis’.” Sociology 52(3): 587–603.
Guida, Cecilia. 2017. “L’accoglienza emergenziale. Pratiche di resistenza dei richiedenti asilo e il ruolo dell’antropologo.” Antropologia Pubblica 3(1): 129–147.
Jacobsen, Christine M., Marry-Anne Karlsen, and Shahram Khosravi. 2021. Waiting and the Temporalities of Irregular Migrants. Taylor & Francis.
Kreichauf, Renè and Birgit Glorius. 2021. “Introduction: Displacement, Asylum and the City – Theoretical Approach and Empirical Findings.” Urban Geography 42(7): 869–893.
Kreichauf, Renè and Margit Mayer. 2021.“Negotiating Urban Solidarity: Multiple Agencies and Contested Meaning in the Making of Solidarity Cities.” Urban Geography 42(7): 1–24.
Malkki, Liisa H. 1996. “Speechless Emissaries: Refugees, Humanitarianism, and Dehistoriciza¬tion.” Cultural Anthropology 11(3): 377–404.
Manocchi, Michele. 2014. “Richiedenti asilo e rifugiati: processi di etichettamento e pratiche di Resistenza.” Pp. 85–409 in Rassegna italiana di sociologia. Il Mulino.
Mantovan, Claudia and Elena Ostanel. 2015. Quartieri Contesi. Convivenza, conflitti e governance nelle zone stazione di Padova e Mestre. Milano: Franco Angeli.
Marchetti, Chiara. 2020. “Cities of Exclusion: Are Local Authorities Refusing Asylum Seekers?” Pp. 237–264 in Migration, Borders and Cityzenship, edited by Maurizio Ambrosini, ManlioCinally, David Jacobson. Palgrave Macmillan.
Medici Senza Frontiere. 2016. “Fuori Campo. Richiedenti asilo e rifugiati in Italia: Insediamenti informali e marginalità sociale.” (https://www.medicisenzafrontiere.it/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Fuoricampo2016.pdf).
Mellino, Miguel. 2019. Governare la crisi dei rifugiati. Sovranismo, neoliberalismo, razzismo e accoglienza in Europa. Rome: Deriveapprodi.
Mezzadra, Sandro. 2001. Diritto di fuga. Migrazioni, cittadinanza, globalizzazione. Ombrecorte.
Mezzadra, Sandro and Brett Neilson. 2013. Border as Method, or, the Multiplication of Labour. Durham: Duke University Press.
Osservatorio, Diritti. 2023. “Richiedenti asilo: Hanno diritto all’accoglienza, ma vivono in strada.” (https://www.osservatoriodiritti.it/2023/07/31/richiedenti-asilo/).
Pasian, Pamela, Giulia Storato, and Angela Toffanin. 2020. “Fuori dal sistema. Retisociali e status giuridico di rifugiati in Veneto.” Studi Emigrazione 220: 564–581.
Peano, Irene. 2021. “Turbolences in Encampment Archipelago: Conflicting Mobilities Between Migration Labour and Logistics in Italian Agro-food Enclaves.” Mobilities 16(2): 55–74.
Pinelli, Barbara. 2017. “Control and Abandonment: The Power of Surveillance on Refugees in Italy, During and After the Mare Nostrum Operation.” Antipode 50(3): 725–747.
Pitzalis, Silvia. 2020. “Il continuum dell’emergenza. Criticità strutturali e mutamenti nel sistema di accoglienza prima e durante la pandemia da Covid-19.” Illuminazioni 53: 56–85.
Pitzalis, Silvia. 2021. “Città del desiderio. Riflessioni antropologiche sulla presenza dei richiedenti asilo nella città metropolitana di Bologna.” Pp. 175–203 in Presenza migrante tra spazi urbani e non urbani. Etnografie su processi, dinamiche e modalità di accoglienza, edited by Francesca Declich, Sivlia Pitzalis. Milano: Meltemi editore.
Sanò, Giuliana, Giulia Storato, and Francesco Della Puppa. 2021. “Interstitial Urban Spaces: Housing Strategies and the Use of the City by Homeless Asylum Seekers and Refugees in Trento, Italy.” Social Antropology 29(4): 1–15.
Sanò, Giuliana and Francesco Della Puppa. 2021. “The Multiple Facets of (im)Mobility. A Multisited Ethnography on Territorialisation Esperiences and Mobility Trajectories of Asylum Seekers and Refugees Outside the Italian Reception System.” Journal of Modern Italian Studies 26(5): 552–568.
Sanò, Giuliana and Omid Firouzi Tabar. 2021. “The ‘Double Emergency’ and the Securitization of the Humanitarian Approach in the Italian Reception System within the Pandemic Crisis.” Dve Domovini/Two Homelands 54: 155–170.
Semprebon, Michela. 2021. “Towards a Parallel Exceptional Welfare System: The Scaling Down and Out of Forced Migrants Reception in Italy.” Urban Geography 42: 915–936.
Sorgoni, Barbara. 2011. Etnografia dell’accoglienza. Rifugiati e richiedenti asilo a Ravenna. Rome: Cisu.
Stopani, Antonio and Marta Pampuro. 2018. “Despite Citizenship. Autonomie migranti e diritto alla città. L’occupazione dell'Ex Moi a Torino.” Revista Interdisciplinar de Mobilidade Humana 26: 55–74.
Tazzioli, Martina. 2018. “The Temporal Borders of Asylum. Temporality of Control in the EU Border Regime.” Political Geography 64: 13–22.
Zamponi, Lorenzo. 2017. “Practices of Solidarity: Direct Social Action, Politicisation and Refugee Solidarity Activism in Italy.” Mondi Migranti 11(3): 97–117.
Copyright (c) 2024 Omid Firouzi Tabar