„Já jsem právně úplně mimo“ – Zkušenosti rodičů z homoparentálních rodin v České republice
Roč.19,č.2(2022)
Rodičovství: plány, formy a zkušenosti
The article focuses on the definition and description of basic forms of parenthood in homoparental families, i.e. families in which a child or children are raised by two parents of the same sex. The findings are based on the results of a qualitative phenomenological survey involving 37 in-depth interviews with same-sex parents. The research approach emphasised the actors’ views. Homoparental families are specific in the Czech Republic in that the lack of equality of social parents is currently supported by legislation. Since same-sex parents feel equal in terms of the relationship with their child concerning both parental responsibility and childcare mutual replaceability, they have a critical perception of the legal inequality of social parents, who are not permitted by legislation to assume the role of the legal representative of a shared child. The declaration of parental equality with respect to the child can be interpreted as one of the strategies that same-sex parents have adopted in terms of strengthening the position of social parents. The deeper analysis of the data revealed differences in the parenting experiences of two types of same-sex parents. Lesbian women perceive the relationship with the child that they gave birth to differently to the relationship with a child that their partner gave birth to, while gay men deny or play down the importance of such differences.
homoparental family, kinship, social parenthood, LGBT, motherhood, fatherhood
BARNES, John Arundel. 1961. „Physical and Social Kinship.“ Philosophy of Sciences 28(3): 296–299.
BARNARD, Alan a Jonathan SPENCER. 1996. Encyclopedia of Social and Cultural Anthropology. London: Routledge.
BOS, Henny, Nanette GARTRELL, Jaap ROELEVELD a Guuske, LEDOUX. 2016. „Civic Competence of Dutch Children in Female Same-Sex Parent Families: A Comparison with Children of Opposite-sex Parents.“ Youth & Society 48(5): 628–648.
BUREŠOVÁ, Kateřina. 2020. Rodičovství a partnerství gayů a leseb v českém právu. Praha: SoÚ AV ČR. Cit 15. června 2022 (https://www.soc.cas.cz/sites/default/files/publikace/buresova-rodicovstvi_a_partnerstvi_gayu_a_leseb_v_ceskem_pravu.pdf).
BÜCHLER, Andrea a Helen KELLER (eds.). 2016. Family Forms and Parenthood. Theory, and Practice of Article 8 ECHR In Europe. Cambridge: Intersentia.
CAMMU, Nola. 2019. „‚Legal Multi-parenthood‘ in Context: Experiences of Parents in Light of the Dutch Proposed Family Law Reforms.“ Family and Law. DOI: 10.5553/FenR/.000042
CRESWELL, John W. 2013. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design. Choosing Among Five Approaches. London: SAGE.
CVVM. 2019. Postoje veřejnosti k právům homosexuálů – květen 2019. Tisková zpráva. Cit. 10. května 2022 (https://cvvm.soc.cas.cz/media/com_form2content/documents/c2/a4940/f9/ov190607.pdf).
CVVM. 2020. Postoje českých občanů k partnerství, manželství a rodičovství – únor 2020. Cit. 10. května 2022 (https://cvvm.soc.cas.cz/media/com_form2content/documents/c2/a5175/f9/ov200325.pdf).
ČSÚ. 2013. Partnerské svazky osob stejného pohlaví v České republice a v Evropě. Cit. 10. května 2022 (https://www.czso.cz/documents/10180/20533820/csav102413opr.pdf/952872bd-1745-4ce0-a21b-c30bbc03ef47?version=1.0).
ČSÚ. 2020. Demografická příručka 2019. Praha: ČSÚ. Cit. 10. května 2022 (https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/demograficka-prirucka-2019).
DEMPSEY, Deborah. 2012. „More Like a Donor or More Like a Father? Gay Men’s Concepts of Relatedness to Children.“ Sexualities 15(2): 156–174.
EMMEL, Nick. 2013. Sampling and Choosing Cases in Qualitative Research. A Realist Approach. London: SAGE.
FIŠEROVÁ, Vlasta. 1996. „Rodina.“ Pp. 940–943 in Velký sociologický slovník. Praha: Karolinum.
GABB, Jacqui. 2004. „Critical Differentials: Querying the Contrarieties between Research on Lesbian Parent Families.“ Sexualities 7(2): 171–87.
GABB, Jacqui. 2005. „Lesbian M/Otherhood: Strategies of Familial-Linguistic Management in Lesbian Parent Families.“ Sociology 39(4): 585–603.
GATES, Gary J. 2015. „Marriage and Family: LGBT Individuals and Same-sex Couples.“ The Future of Children 25(2): 67–87.
GOLDBERG, Abbie E. a Maureen PERRY-JENKINS. 2007. „The Division of Labor and Perceptions of Parental Roles: Lesbian Couples across the Transition to Parenthood.“ Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 24(2): 297–318.
GUEST, Greg, Kathleen M. MacQUEEN a Emily E. NAMEY. 2012. Applied Thematic Analysis. London: Sage.
JOAMETS, Kristi a Tanel KERIKMÄE. 2016. „European Dilemmas of the Biological Versus Social Father: The Case of Estonia.“ Baltic Journal of Law & Politics 9(2): 23–42
HAŠKOVÁ, Hana, Hana MAŘÍKOVÁ, Zdeněk SLOBODA a Kristýna POSPÍŠILOVÁ. 2022. „Childlessness and Barriers to Gay Parenthood in Czechia.“ Social Inclusion 10(3). https://doi.org/10.17645/si.v10i3.5246
HAŠKOVÁ, Hana a Zdeněk SLOBODA. 2018. „Negotiating Access to Assisted Reproduction Technologies in a Post-Socialist Heteronormative Context,“ Journal of International Women's Studies 20(1): Article 5. Cit 10. dubna (https://vc.bridgew.edu/jiws/vol20/iss1/5).
KINSEY, Caroline L. 2009. „The Role of The Psychological Parent in the Dissolution of the Homosexual Relationship.“ International Journal of Discrimination and the Law 10(3): 133–148.
KUCHAŘOVÁ, Věra et al. 2019. Česká rodina na počátku 21. století. Životní podmínky, vztahy, potřeby. Praha: Sociologické nakladatelství.
KUCHAŘOVÁ, Věra, Jana BARVÍKOVÁ, Sylva HÖHNE, Olga NEŠPOROVÁ, Jana PALONCYOVÁ a Lucie VIDOVIĆOVÁ. 2020. Zpráva o rodině 2020. Praha: VÚPSV. Cit 20. dubna 2022 (https://www.mpsv.cz/documents/20142/225508/Zpr%C3%A1va%20o%20rodin%C4%9B%202020.pdf/c3bdc63d-9c95-497d-bded-6a15e9890abd).
KUTÁLKOVÁ, Petra. 2015. Duhové rodiny ve stínu státu. Praha: Prague Pride. Cit 15- května 2022 (https://praguepride.cz/cs/kdo-jsme/media-download/publikace/12-duhove-rodiny-ve-stinu-statu/fil).
KUTÁLKOVÁ, Petra a Magdalena SKŘIVÁNKOVÁ. 2018. Sešívané rodiny. Nový život zevnitř i zvenku. Praha: Platforma pro rovnoprávnost, uznání a diverzitu.
MALMQUIST, Anna a Sonja HÖJERSTRÖM. 2020. „Constructions of Surrogates, Egg Donors, and Mothers: Swedish Gay Fathers’ Narratives.“ Feminism & Psychology 30(4): 508–528.
MARTIAL, Agnès. 2019. „Multi-Parenthood and Contemporary Family Forms in French Studies.“ Antropologia 6 (2): 13–26. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.14672/ada2019157613-26
MAŘÍKOVÁ, Hana a Marta VOHLÍDALOVÁ. 2019. „Bariéry versus preferované formy rodičovství u neheterosexuální populace.“ Fórum sociální politiky 13(6): 20–26.
MAZREKAJ, Deni, Kristof DE WITTE a Sofie CABUS. 2020. „School Outcomes of Children Raised by Same-sex Parents: Evidence from Administrative Panel Data.“ American Sociological Review 85(5): 830–856.
MCINERNEY, Anna, Mary CREANER a Elizabeth NIXON. 2021. „The Motherhood Experiences of Non-Birth Mothers in Same-Sex Parent Families.“ Psychology of Women Quarterly 45(3): 279–293. DOI: 03616843211003072
MEEZAN, William a Jonathan RAUCH. 2005. „Gay Marriage, Same-sex Parenting, and America’s Children.“ The Future of Children 15(2): 97–115.
MENDOS, Lucas Ramón, Kellyn BOTHA, Rafael CARRANO LELIS, Enrique López de la PEÑA, Ilia SAVELEVAND a Daron TAN. 2020. State-Sponsored Homofobia 2020. Global Legislation Overview Update. Geneva: ILGA. Cit. 12. června 2022 (https://ilga.org/downloads/ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_overview_update_December_2020.pdf).
MOŽNÝ, Ivo. 1990. Moderní rodina. Mýty a skutečnosti. Brno: Blok.
MURPHY, Dean A. 2013. „The Desire for Parenthood: Gay Men Choosing to Become Parents through Surrogacy.“ Journal of Family Issues 34(8): 1104–1124.
NEDBÁLKOVÁ, Kateřina, 2011. Matky kuráže. Lesbické rodiny v pozdně moderní společnosti. Praha: Sociologické nakladatelství.
NEŠPOROVÁ, Olga. 2021. Homoparentální rodiny. Praha: VÚPSV. Cit 21. října 2022 (https://katalog.vupsv.cz/Fulltext/vz_486.pdf).
PADAVIC, Irene a Jonniann BUTTERFIELD. 2011. „Mothers, Fathers, and ‚Mathers‘ Negotiating a Lesbian Co-parental Identity.“ Gender & Society 25(2): 176–196.
PATTERSON, Charlotte J. 2006. „Children of Lesbian and Gay Parents.“ Current Directions in Psychological Science 15(5): 241–244.
POLÁŠKOVÁ, Eva. 2009. Plánovaná lesbická rodina. Klíčové aspekty přechodu k rodičovství. Brno: Masarykova univerzita.
RYAN-FLOOD, Róisín. 2005. „Contested Heteronormativities: Discourses of Fatherhood among Lesbian Parents in Sweden and Ireland.“ Sexualities 8(2): 189–204.
SHIPMAN, Beccy a Carol SMART. 2007. „‚It's Made a Huge Difference‘: Recognition, Rights and the Personal Significance of Civil Partnership.“ Sociological Research Online 12(1): 129–139.
SLOBODA, Zdeněk. 2016. Dospívání, rodičovství a (homo)sexualita. Libčice nad Vltavou: Pasparta Publishing.
SOKOLOVÁ, Věra. 2004. „„A co děti? …‘ Gay a lesbické rodičovství: Homofobie a genderové stereotypy v české společnosti.“ Pp. 81–96 in Lenka FORMÁNKOVÁ a Kristýna RYTÍŘOVÁ (eds.). ABC feminismu. Brno: Nesehnutí.
SOKOLOVÁ, Věra. 2009. „Otec, otec a dítě: Gay muži a rodičovství.“ Sociologický časopis 45(1): 1–31.
SURTEES, Nicola a Philip BREMNER. 2020. „Gay and Lesbian Collaborative Co-Parenting in New Zealand and the United Kingdom: ‚The Law Doesn’t Protect the Third Parent‘.“ Social & Legal Studies 29(4): 507–526.
UNESCO. 2019. Report of the IBC on Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) and Parenthood. Cit 20. října 2022 (https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000367957).
WINTER, Broneyn. 2021. The Political Economy of Same-Sex Marriage. A Feminist Critique. London, New York: Routledge.
ZLOTNIK, Daniella. 2016. Children and the Changing Picture of Family: A Child-Centred and Rights Based Approach to Multiple Parent Families. Magisterská práce, Leiden University, Faculty of Law. Cit 15. června 2022 (https://www.universiteitleiden.nl/binaries/content/assets/rechtsgeleerdheid/instituut-voor-privaatrecht/daniella-zlotnik---thesis---a-child-centered-and-rights-based-approach-to-multiple-parent-families-final-11.7.2016..pdf).
Tato práce je licencována pod Mezinárodní licencí Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 .
Copyright © 2022 Olga Nešporová