Does NATO Enlargement Spread Democracy? The Democratic Stabilization of Western Balkan Countries.

Zdeněk Kříž, Markéta Stixová

Abstrakt

This article deals with NATO enlargement toward Western Balkan countries and tries to answer the question of whether NATO enlargement has contributed to the democratic stabilization of the Western Balkans. The authors conclude that NATO has truly contributed to the democratic stabilization of candidate countries. Nevertheless, we have no evidence supporting the thesis that the democratic stabilization of Albania, Croatia, or Macedonia is progressing solely due to the NATO enlargement policy; it is not clear that NATO is viewed as one of the Western institutions into which these countries want to join. On the one hand, this study shows that NATO enlargement may not have as significant an impact on democratization as has been hoped for by its proponents, who started this process in the mid-90s. On the other hand, the impact of NATO on the consolidation of democratic regimes in candidate countries is by no means zero or even marginal.

Bibliografická citace

Kříž, Z., & Stixová, M. (2012). Does NATO Enlargement Spread Democracy? The Democratic Stabilization of Western Balkan Countries.. Středoevropské politické studie, 14(1), 1-34. Získáno z https://journals.muni.cz/cepsr/article/view/4570

Klíčová slova

NATO enlargement; democratization; Western Balkans;

Plný Text:

HTML (English)

Reference

Zobrazit literaturu Skrýt literaturu

Abazi E. (2004): Defense Reform of the Albanian Armed Forces: Democratization and Transformation, The Quarterly Journal, Vol. III, No. 3, p. 31-41, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Council of Ministers (2006): National Strategy for Development and Integration, NSDI 2005 Annual Progress Report, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Council of Ministers (2007): The Prime Minister's Address to the 62nd Session of the UN General Assembly, 28 September, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Council of Ministers (2008a): National Strategy for Development and Integration NSDI 2006 – 2007 Annual Progress Report, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Council of Ministers (2008b): National Strategy for Development and Integration 2007 – 2013, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Government (2005): The Military Strategy of the Republic of Albania, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Government (2007): Sali Berisha, Prime Minister of Republic of Albania, Address at the 53 Annual Session of NATO Parliamentary Assembly, 9 October 2007, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Helsinki Committee (2009): Preliminary Report on the Conduct of the Electoral Process of June 28, 2009, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2005): Government Program 2005 – 2009, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2009): Albania and MAP, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2010): Albania and PfP, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Albanian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Why does Albania Like to Join NATO?, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Asmus, R. D. (2002): Opening NATO’s Door: How the Alliance Remade Itself for a New Era, New York, Columbia University Press.
Bertelsmann Stiftung (2003a): Bertelsmann Trasformation Index 2003: Albania, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Bertelsmann Stiftung (2003b): Bertelsmann Trasformation Index 2003: Macedonia, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Bertelsmann Stiftung (2008): Bertelsmann Trasformation Index 2008: Albania, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Božinović, D. (2007): Transforming Society – Croatia’s Way to NATO, Zagreb, Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Cehulić, L – Vukadinović, R. (2001): Development of Civil-Military Relations in Croatia, in Pantev, P. (ed.): Civil-Military Relations in South-East Europe. A Survey of the National Perspectives and of the Adaptation Process to the Partnership for Peace Standards, Vienna, National Defence Academy Vienna 2001, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Congressional Research Service (2008): CRS Report for Congress, NATO Enlargement:Albania, Croatia and Possible Future Candidates, 6 October, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian Government (2003): The Program of the Government of the Republic of Croatia for the 2003 – 2007 Mandate, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian Government (2007): Sanader gives talk on benefits from EU and NATO membership, 15 May, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian Government (2008): Mesic, Sanader reaffirm commitment to NATO values, 11 April, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian Government (2010): PM Sanader on benefits of NATO membership, 29 March, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian Ministry of Defence (2008): Annual Exchange of Information on Defence Planning 2008, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian Parliament (2010): The Constitution of the Republic of Croatia, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian President (2002): Stjepan Mesić, President of the Republic of Croatia, Address to 22 November – Prague, Czech Republic – NATO Summit, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian President (2006): Stjepan Mesić, President of the Republic of Croatia, speech at Statehood Day reception, 21 June, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Croatian President (2007): Stjepan Mesić, President of the Republic of Croatia, address at the conference “The Balkans at the Crossroads,” 4 December, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Dahl, R. A. (1989): Democracy and Its Critics, London, Yale University Press.
Diamond, L. (2003): Defining and Developing Democracy, in R.A. Dahl – I. Shapiro – J.A. Cheibub, (eds.): The Democracy Sourcebook, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Epstein, R.A. (2005): NATO Enlargement and the Spread of Democracy: Evidence and Expectations, Security Studies, Vol. XIV, No. 1, p. 52-60.
Freedom House (2003): Country Report – Macedonia 2003, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Freedom House (2005): Country Report – Croatia 2005, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Freedom House (2008a): Country Report – Croatia 2008, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Freedom House (2008b): Nations in Transit 2008, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Freedom House (2009a): Country Report – Macedonia 2009, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Freedom House (2009b): Nations in Transit 2009, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Freedom House (2009c): Nations in Transit: Croatia 2003 – 2009, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Freedom House (2009d): Nations in Transit 2009: Albania, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Gheciu, A. (2005): Security Institutions as Agents of Socialization? NATO and the 'New Europe', International Organization, Vol. LIX, No. 4, p. 973-1012.
GONG (2008): Final Report on Election of Representatives to the Croatian Parliament, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Huntington, S. (1991): The Third Wave: Democratization in Central and Eastern Europe, Norman, University of Oklahoma Press.
Kajsiu, B. (2005): Process of Reform of Civil-Military Relations, the Democratic Control of Armed Forces and the Security Sector in Albania, in P. H. Fluri – G. E. Gustenau – P. I. Pantev, (eds.): The Evolution of Civil-Military Relations in South East Europe. Continuing Democratic Reform and Adapting to the Needs of Fighting Terrorism, Germany, Physica-Verlag Heidelberg, on-line text via (http://www.springerlink.com/), [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Legislationline (2006): Law on the State Electoral Commission, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Assembly (1992): The Constitution of the Republic of Macedonia, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Government (2006): Program of the Government (2006 – 2010), on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Government (2009a): Nikola Gruevski, Prime Minister of the Republic of Macedonia, address at the 11th Conference of the Balkan Political Club “Macedonia on Its Road to NATO and EU,” 20 February, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Government (2009b): Nikola Gruevski, Prime Minister of the Republic of Macedonia, address at the 45th Munich Security Conference, 8 February, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Ministry of Defence (2004): Annual National program 2004-2005, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Ministry of Defence (1997): Republic of Macedonia and NATO, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Ministry of Defence (2006a): Annual National Program 2006-2007, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Ministry of Defence (2006b): Our Way to NATO, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Macedonian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2008): Macedonia & NATO, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Marshall Center (2009a): History of the George C. Marshall Center, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Marshall Center (2009b): Statistical Fact Sheet, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Meyer, S. E. (2003): Carcass of Dead Policies: The Irrelevance of NATO, Parameters, Vol. XXIII, No. 4, p. 83-97.
Michta A. A. (2009): NATO Enlargement post-1989: Successful Adaptation or Decline?, Contemporary European History, Vol. XVIII, No. 3, p. 363-376.
NATO (1994): Partnership for Peace: Framework Document, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2003a): Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, Secretary General, NATO; Stjepan Mesic, President of the Republic of Croatia, Joint Press Conference, 3 December, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2003b): NATO’s role in FYROM, 1 April, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2004): Jaap de Hoof Scheffer, Secretary General, NATO, speech at the Parlament of the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, 27 May, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2005): Study on NATO Enlargement, 3 September, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2006a): Alessandro Minuto Rizzo, Deputy Secretary General, NATO, speech at the Law Faculty of the University of Zagreb, Croatia, 23 February, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2006b): Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, Secretary General, NATO, Speech at the Albanian parliament, 6 July, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2007): Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, Secretary General, NATO; Bamir Topi, President of the Republic of Albania, Joint Press Conference, 19 October, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2008): Bucharest Summit Declaration, 3 April, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2009a): NATO’s relations with Albania, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2009b): NATO’s relations with the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2009c): Partnership for Peace Training and Educational Centres hold tenth commandants’ conference, 5 – 8 October, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2010a): Education and Training, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2010b): Membership Action Plan (MAP), on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO (2011): Partnership for Peace, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO Defense College (2011), on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO PA (2002): Mission Reports, 16 –18 September, Zagreb, Croatia, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
NATO PA (2007): The Three Adriatic Aspirants: Capabilities and Preparations, Annual Session, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
OSCE (2007): Mission to Croatia, Reactions in Croatia to the ICTY verdict on the “Vukovar Three,” 2 October, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
OSCE (2008): Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, Final Report on the 1 June 2008 Parliamentary Elections in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
OSCE (2010): Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, reports on elections, 2001, 2005, 2009, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
OSCE (2011): Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights – Elections, FYROM, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
PfP Consortium (2011), Pfp Consortium of Defense Academies and Security Studies Institutes, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Pietz, T. (2006): Defense Reform and Conversion in Albania, Macedonia and Croatia, Bonn, Bonn International Center for Conversion, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Pridham, G. (2009): Democratic Consolidation in the Czech Republic: Comparative Perspectives after Twenty Years of Political Change, Czech Journal of Political Science, Vol. XVI, No. 4, p. 267-287.
Reiter, D. (2001): Why NATO Enlargement Does Not Spread Democracy, International Security, Vol. XXV, No. 4, p. 41-67.
Rupp, R. E. (2002): NATO Enlargement: All Aboard? Destination Unknown, East European Quarterly, Vol. XXXVI, No. 3, p. 341-363.
Sjursen, H. (2004): On the Identity of NATO, International Affairs, The Transatlantic Relationship, Vol. LXXX, No. 4, p. 687-703.
Smith, M. (2000): NATO Enlargement during the Cold War. Strategy and System in the Western Alliance, Houndmills, Palgrave.
Spirovski, I. (2001): Separation of Powers between the Political Branches of Government in the Republic of Macedonia, Cuestiones Constitucionales, No. 5, July – December, p. 219-234.
Staničić, M. (2005): The Evolution of Civil-Military Relations in South East Europe: The Case of Croatia, in: in P. H. Fluri – G. E. Gustenau – P. I. Pantev, (eds.): The Evolution of Civil-Military Relations in South East Europe. Continuing Democratic Reform and Adapting to the Needs of Fighting Terrorism, Germany, Physica-Verlag Heidelberg, on-line text via (http://www.springerlink.com), [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Stojarová, V. - Mareš, M. - Stojar, R. - Prtina, S. (2010): Security perspectives of Western Balkan countries. Brno : Centrum pro studium demokracie a kultury, 2010. 123 s.
The Institute for Democracy and Mediation (2007): Albanian Perceptions on NATO Integration, March – May 2007, June, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Tudoroiu, T. (2007): The Geography of the Eastern Enlargement: Present and Future Limits, European Union Studies Association, 17 – 19 May.
Vankovska, B. (2005): Civil-Military Relations in Macedonia: Between Peace and War, in P. H. Fluri – G. E. Gustenau – P. I. Pantev, (eds.): The Evolution of Civil-Military Relations in South East Europe. Continuing Democratic Reform and Adapting to the Needs of Fighting Terrorism, Germany, Physica-Verlag Heidelberg, on-line text, [cit. 18. 10. 2011].
Waterman, H. – Zagorcheva, D. – Reiter, D. (2002): NATO and Democracy, International Security, Vol. XXVI, No. 3, p. 221-235.
Zachariadis, N. (2003): External Intervention and Domestic Ethnic Conflict in Yugoslav Macedonia, Political Science Quarterly, Vol. CXVIII, No. 2, p. 259-279.



Copyright (c) 2012 Zdeněk Kříž, Markéta Stixová

Creative Commons License
Tato práce je licencována pod licencí Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.