Democracy and International Intervention in Bosnia and Herzegovina

Gergana Císařová Dimitrová

Democracy and International Intervention in Bosnia and Herzegovina

Roč.7,č.1(2005)

PDF (English)

The article analyzes international intervention in Bosnia and Herzegovina and assesses the effects it has had on political developments and democratization in the country. The paper is especially focused on mapping the ongoing debate among policy analysts over the benefits of direct and proactive international intervention and the dangers inherent in the prolonged denial of self-government to the Bosnian people. It argues that while international intervention has often been visibly successful in pushing through major reforms and political changes, the undemocratic character in which it has been carried out is far from unproblematic. The international community in Bosnia is not accountable to Bosnian citizens, its extensive governance powers have been largely exempt from democratic checks and balances, and international action has tended to sidestep and marginalize local institutions and the local political process, thus undermining the sustainability of the achieved improvements. On the whole, the effective, if not official, protectorate has been an unsuitable way of ‘teaching’ Bosnians what democracy is. Finally, the article uses the case of Bosnia to draw some general lessons for international intervention in post-conflict areas.

Klíčová slova:
Bosnia and Herzegovina; international intervention; Office of the High Representative; OHR; political situation; democratization; legitimacy of international intervention; post-conflict management;

Reference

Ashdown, Paddy (2002): Inaugural Speech by Paddy Ashdown, the High Representative for Bosnia and Herzegovina, State Parliament of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Sarajevo, 27 May 2002. CEPS Europa South-East Monitor 37, 1-8. URL: http://www.ceps.be.
Ashdown, Paddy (2003): Bosnia Needs Accelerated Reforms. IWPR Balkan Crisis Report 447, 23 July 2003. E-mail distribution version. Paging not available. Also available at URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
Ashdown, Paddy (December 2003): Peace Stabilisation: The Lessons from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Lecture at the London School of Economics. Paging not available. URL: http://www.lse.ac.uk/Depts/global/Ashdown.htm.
Ashdown, Paddy (October 2004): Speech by the High Representative, Paddy Ashdown, to the Venice Commission. Venice, Press Release from 13 October 2004. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
Ashdown, Paddy (December 2004): Bosnia and Herzegovina: the Agenda for 2005. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
Braithwaite, Julian (September 2004): Don’t miss the train to Europe. (Originally published in Nezavisne Novine). Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
Beecroft, Robert (2004): Comment: Parting Thoughts on Bosnia’s Paralysis. IWPR Balkan Crisis Report 506, 8 July 2004. Paging not available. URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
Belloni, Roberto (2003): Dubious Democracy by Fiat. Balkan Reconstruction Report, 20 August. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in August 2003.
Bieber, Florian (2003): Far From Raj. Balkan Reconstruction Report, 31 July. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in July 2003.
Bose, Sumantra (2002): Bosnia after Dayton. Nationalist Partition and International Intervention. London: Hurst & Co.
BRR (Balkan Reconstruction Report) (4 April 2003): Bosnia: Ashdown Reins in Bosnian Serbs. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in April 2003.
BRR (29 July 2003): Too Much and Not Enough. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in July 2003.
BRR (11 August 2003): West (and East) Side Story. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in August 2003.
BRR (21 August 2003): Bosnia: Mostar Future in Ashdown’s Hands. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in August 2003.
BRR (1 September 2003): Doing Away with Segregation. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in September 2003.
BRR (3 September 2003): Bosnian Parties Urged to Unblock Reforms. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in September 2003.
BRR (17 September 2003): Living in Paradox. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in September 2003.
BRR (6 November 2003): Public Broadcasting Imbroglio. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in November 2003.
BRR (5 January 2004): A Tax reform for Bosnia. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in January 2004.
Carpenter, Ted Galen (2002): High-Handed Nation Building: The West Brings ‘Democracy’ to Bosnia. In Gary Dempsey (ed.) Exiting the Balkan Thicket, 11-32. Washington D.C.: CATO Institute.
Chandler, David (2000): Bosnia: Faking Democracy After Dayton. Second Edition. London: Pluto Press.
Commission for Reforming the City of Mostar (2003): Recommendations of the Commission. Report of the Chairman. December. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
ESI (European Stability Initiative) (2000): Reshaping international priorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Part Two: International Power in Bosnia. Berlin: ESI. URL: http://www.esiweb.org.
ESI (2001a): In Search of Politics: The Evolving International Role in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Berlin, Sarajevo: ESI, Discussion Paper. URL: http://www.esiweb.org.
ESI (2001b): Reshaping International Priorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Part Three: The End of the Nationalist Regimes and the Future of the Bosnian State. Berlin: ESI. URL: http://www.esiweb.org.
ESI (2003): Open Letter to Lord Ashdown: After the Bonn Powers. Sarajevo. July 16. IWPR Balkan Crisis Report 447, 23 July 2003. E-mail distribution version. Paging not available. Also available at URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
ESI (2004): Governance and Democracy in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Post-Industrial Society and the Authoritarian Temptation. Berlin, Brussels, Sarajevo: Part of the project ‘Governance Assessment of Bosnia and Herzegovina’. URL: http://www.esiweb.org.
Hayden, Robert (2002): Let Dayton Be Dayton. In Gary Dempsey (ed.) Exiting the Balkan Thicket, 67-79. Washington D.C.: CATO Institute.
Hays, Donald (2004): Keynote Address by Principal Deputy HR Donald Hays at a Conference on ‘Lessons We Re-Learned in the Balkan Conflicts’. Boston College, October. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
ICG (International Crisis Group) (2001): Bosnia: Reshaping the International Machinery. Sarajevo, Brussels: ICG, Balkans Report No. 121. URL: http://www.crisisweb.org.
ICG (2002): Bosnia’s Alliance For (Smallish) Change. Sarajevo, Brussels: ICG, Balkans Report No.132. URL: http://www.crisisweb.org.
ICG (2003a): Bosnia’s Nationalist Governments: Paddy Ashdown and The Paradoxes of State Building. Sarajevo, Brussels: ICG, Balkans Report No. 146. URL: http://www.crisisweb.org.
ICG (2003b): Building Bridges in Mostar. Sarajevo, Brussels: ICG, Europe Report No. 150. URL: http://www.crisisweb.org.
ICG (2003c): Thessaloniki and after II: The EU and Bosnia. Sarajevo, Brussels: ICG, Balkans Briefing. URL: http://www.crisisweb.org.
IWPR (Institute for War and Peace Reporting): (2 July 2004a) Bosnian Serbs Warn of Backlash Over Ashdown Sackings. Balkan Crisis Report 505. Paging not available. URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
IWPR (2 July 2004b): The Internationals and the Balkans: Time for Change? Debate between Gerald Knaus and Nicholas Whyte. Balkan Crisis Report 505. Paging not available. URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
IWPR (15 July 2004): Bosnia: Serbs Threaten Constitutional Crisis. Balkan Crisis Report 507. Paging not available. URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
IWPR (12 November 2004): Calls Grow for Ashdown to Surrender “Imperial” Powers. Balkan Crisis Report 525. Paging not available. URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
IWPR (14 January 2005): New Bosnian Serb Government Underwhelms. Balkan Crisis Report 536. Paging not available. URL: http://www.iwpr.net.
Knaus, Gerald and Felix Martin (2003): Travails of The European Raj: Lessons from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Journal of Democracy 14 (3), 60-74.
OHR (Office of the High Representative) (June 1998): Decision on the Establishment of the Independent Media Commission. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
OHR (March 2001): Decision Combining the Competencies of the Independent Media Commission and the Telecommunications Regulatory Agency. Sarajevo. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
OHR (October 2002): High Representative to Vet New Ministers. Sarajevo. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
OHR (June 2003): High Representative Reaction Following Failure tTo Appoint Canton 7 Government. Sarajevo. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
OHR (January 2004): Decision Enacting the Statute of the City of Mostar. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
OHR (March 2004): OHR Mission Implementation Plan 2004. Sarajevo. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
OHR (August 2004): OHR Announces Downsizing in Line with BiH’s Progress towards Full Statehood. Sarajevo. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
Perry, Valery (2003): Bosnia, an Intellectual Raj. Balkan Reconstruction Report, 24 July. Paging not available. URL: http://balkanreport.tol.cz. Accessed in July 2003.
TOL (13 December 2004): Bosnia: A Rock and a Hard Place. Paging not available. URL: http://www.tol.cz. Accessed in December 2004.
Westendorp, Carlos (1997): Speech by the High Representative, Carlos Westendorp, to the Peace Implementation Council. 9 December. Paging not available. URL: http://www.ohr.int.
IMC (Independent Media Commission) (2000): Media and Democratization in Bosnia and Herzegovina. IMC White Paper. URL: http://www.mediaonline.ba/mediaonline/attach_eng/334.pdf.
USIP (United States Institute of Peace) (2000): Bosnia’s Next Five Years: Dayton and Beyond. Washington: USIP, Special Report No. 62. URL: http://www.usip.org.
USIP (2002): Taking Stock and Looking Forward. Intervention in the Balkans and Beyond. Washington: USIP, Special Report No. 83. URL: http://www.usip.org.

Metriky

1171

Views

257

PDF (English) views

Tato práce je licencována pod Mezinárodní licencí Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 .

PDF (English)