Europeanisation and Euro-scepticism: Experiences from Poland and the Czech Republic

Søren Riishøj

Abstrakt

The first section of this article briefly highlights the concepts of “national identity” and “europeanisation”. Although seeming to have the same “core-meaning”, these concepts have been explained differently. Broadly speaking, “europeanisation” has been studied by using either rationalist “objective” or “subjective” social-constructivist type argumentation. Moving to more ordinary politics, attitudes to the EU seem to be more linked to national interests and to a smaller extent based on identities. Furthermore, like national identity “euro-scepticism” has been examined discursively underlining the impact of mutually overlapping (multiple) identities and European identity versus national identity.
Euro-scepticism may be cleavage based, i.e. connected to particular cultural, geographic and socio-economic factors like land-town, work-capital, church and society or be connected to concrete issues and the negotiations with the EU. In addition, some studies of Euro-scepticism have been party based. In those cases a distinction between “soft” and “hard” euro-scepticism may be useful.
The last section will concentrate on Poland and the Czech Republic. Also other CEECs will be mentioned. In the case of Poland, euro-scepticism mostly can be found in the conservative-traditionalist camp, in the eastern part of the country and geographically in the small towns and in the land districts, sometimes in a catholic-fundamentalist and agrarian shape. In the case of the Czech Republic, the main focus will be on the difference in the attitudes of former president Václav Havel and the current president Václav Klaus, the policy of the social democrats (ČSSD) and soft and hard scepticism expressed by the liberal Civic Democratic Party (ODS) and the communists (KSČM).

Bibliografická citace

Riishøj, S. (2004). Europeanisation and Euro-scepticism: Experiences from Poland and the Czech Republic. Středoevropské politické studie, 6(4). Získáno z https://journals.muni.cz/cepsr/article/view/4051

Klíčová slova

national identity; European identity; Euro-scepticism; Poland; the Czech Republic;

Reference

Zobrazit literaturu Skrýt literaturu

Ágh, Atilla (1998): The Politics of Central Europe, London: Sage.
Batory, Agnes, (2002): “Europe and the Hungarian Parliamentary Elections of April 2002”, RIIA/PERN Election Briefing No. 1.
Bartoszewski, Wladislaw (2003): ”Europas Identität nach der Osterweiterung”, ZEI Discussion Paper C127, www.zei.de
Bielasiak, Jacek (2002): “Determinants of public opinion differences on EU accession in Poland”, Europe-Asia Studies.
Bjurulf, Bo (2001): ”How did Sweden Manage the European Union”, ZEI Discussion Paper C 96, www.zei.de
Börzel, Tanja A. (2003): “Shaping and Taking EU Politics: Member state Responses to Europeanisation”, Queen’s Papers on Europeanisation, No. 2.
Börzel, Tanja A. (1999): “Towards Convergence in Europe? Institutional Adoption to Europeanisation in Germany and Spain”, Journal of Common Market Studies, 37:4, 573-596.
Branner, Hans, Morten Kelstrup (eds.) (2000), Denmark’s policy towards Europe after 1945, History, Theory and Options, Odense University Press.
Brodský, Jiří (2001), “The Czech Experience of Identity”, in: Drulák, Petr (ed.), National and European Identities in EU-Enlargement, Prague: Institute of International Relations
Bruss, Martin (2000): “Governance Capacity as a Key Factor in Preparing Accession to the European Union: A Survey of the Discussion”, Perspectives, No.14, Prague.
Bugge, Peter (2000): “Czech Perceptions of the Perspective of EU membership, Havel versus Klaus, European University Institute, Working Paper RSC, No. 10.
Buras, Piotr (2001): “Poland and the Discussion on the Future of the European Union”, 6/01, Center for International Relations, www.csm.org.pl
Daskalov, Roumen (2004), The Making of a Nation in the Balkans, Historiography of the Bulgarian Revival, Budapest: CEU Press.
Drulák, Petr (2001), National and European Identities in EU-Enlargement, Prague: Institute of International Relations.
Friis, Lykke (1996): When Europe negotiates, Pd.D.-thesis, Institute of Political Science, Copenhagen.
Gasior-Niemiec, Anna (2003): “Traces of Europeanisation: Poland”, Polish Sociological Review, No. 1: 31-51.
Grote, Jurgen R (2003): “Delimiting Europeanisation”, paper for presentation at the Marburg Conference Session, ECPR, Marburg, 18-21. September 2003.
Gwiazda, Anna (2002): “Europeanisation in Candidate Countries and Eastern Europe”, paper prepared for the EPIC workshop in Florence, EUI, 19-22 September 2002.
Hajos, Boris, Kissiov, Vladimir, Martikonis, Rytis, Martonand, Imrich, Sulca Iveta (2002): “The Future of the European Integration Process: Ideas and Concepts of Candidate Countries”, Discussion Paper C 107 www.zei.de
Hanley, Sean (1999): “Czechs Seek Yet Another Model”, Central Europe Review, Vol. 0, No. 30.
Hanley, Sean (2002): “Europe and the Czech Parliamentary Elections of June 2002”, RIIA/ORN Election Briefing No. 5.
Hanley, Sean (2002): “Party Institutionalisation and Centre-Right Euroscepticism in East Central Europe: the Case of the Civic Democratic Party in the Czech Republic, paper presented for presentation at the 29 the ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops, Turin, 22-27 March 2002.
Hanley, Sean (2002): “The Political Context of EU Accession in the Czech Republic”, The Royal Institute of International Affairs, European Programme, Briefing Paper, October 2002.
Henderson, Karen (ed.) (1999), Back to Europe, Central and Eastern Europe and the European Union, London and Philadelphia: UCL Press.
Hoen, Herman W. (2001): “Good Governance in Central and Eastern Europe: The European Union as an Anchor for Reform”, paper presented at the conference on “Environment challenges in the Process of Expansion of the European Union”, 22-23 March 2001, Opole-Poland.
Holý, L. (1996): The Little Czech and the Great Czech Nation: National identity and the post-communist transformation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Huntington, Samuel P. (1993): “The Clash of Civilisations”, Foreign Affairs, 72 (3), New York.
Johnson, Lonnie R. (2002): Central Europe, enemies, neighbours, friends, NewYork, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kaunismaa, Pekka (1995): ”On the Analysis of National Identity”, paper prepared for the Second European Conference for Sociology 30 August-2 September 1995, Budapest, Hungary.
Kiss, Paszkál (2001): “Hungarians about Their Nation, Others, and Europe, Popular Views in Public”, Report (D5) prepared for the EURONAT project by the European Commission Research DG.
Kupchan, Charles A. (1995): Nationalism and Nationalities in the new Europe, Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
Laffan, Brigid (2003): “Managing Europe from Home: Impact of the EU on Executive Government: A Comparative Analysis”, paper for ECPR Conference, Marburg, September 2003.
Lesaar, Henrik Richard (2001): “Semper Idem? The Relationship of European and National Identities”, in: Drulák, Petr (ed.), National and European Identities in EU-Enlargement, Prague: Institute of International Relations:179-194.
Michnik, Adam (2003): “What Europe means for Poland”, Journal of Democracy, Vol. 14, No. 4.
Musil, Jiri (ed.) (1996), The End of Czechoslovakia”, Budapest: Central European University Press.
The National Idea in Eastern Europe, the Politics of Ethnic and Civic Community” (1996): Canada and US: Gerasimos Augustinos.
Neumann, Iver B. (1999): ”Diskursanalyse av politikk: Forutsetninger og metodeproblemer”, Statsvetenskaplig Tidsskrift, Vol. 102, No. 2.
Neumann, Iver B. (1998): “European Identity, EU expansion, and the Integration/Exclusion Nexus”, Alternatives 23, 397-416.
Morten Kelstrup (1992): “Small States and European Integration”, in Teija Tiikainen, Ib Damgaard Petersen (eds.): Small States and European Integration, Reflections on Theory and Strategy”. Copenhagen Political Studies Press: 136-162.
Schnurbein, Katharina von (2003): “Rozšíření EU- Přistoupení k EU, Vůle lidu? Zájem lidu?“, in Mezinárodní politika, No. 9.
Rhodes, Metthew (1998): “The Idea of Central Europe and Visegrad Cooperation”, International Politics 35: 165-186.
Riish?j, S?ren (1998): “The Czech Republic’s Foreign Policy and Anticipatory Adaption to the EU”, TKI Working paper on European integration and regime formation, No. 29.
A. S. de Rosa (2002): “Reality Changes faster than research: National and supranational identity in social representations of European Community in the context of changes in international relations. In Breakwell, G. and Lyons, E. (eds.), Changing European Identities. Advances in Social Psychology (pp. 381-402), Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
Svetlozar, Andreev. A, (2002): “Path Dependence and External Shocks. The dynamics of the EU enlargement Eastwards”, from Finn Laursen (red.), Comparative regional integration, Ashgate.
Szczerbiak, Aleks, (2001): “Polish Public Opinion: Explaining Declining Support for EU-membership”, Journal of Common Market Studies, Vol. 139, No.1, pp 105-122.
Szczerbiak, Aleks and Paul Taggart (2002): “Theorising Party-Based Euroscepticism: Problems of Definition, Measurement and Causality”, Sussex European Institute, SEI Working Paper No. 69, www.sussex.ac.uk
Taggard, Paul and Aleks Szczerbiak (2001): “Parties, Positions and Europe: Euroscepticism in the EU Candidate States of Central and Eastern Europe”, SEI Working Paper no. 46, Sussex European Institute, www.sussex.ac.uk
Thiesse, Anne-Marie (1999): “Democracy Softens Forces of Change: Inventing National Identity”, Le Monde Diplomatique.
Batory, Agnes (2001): “Hungarian party identities & the question of European Integration”, SEI Working paper no. 49, Sussex European Institute, www.sussex.ac.uk
Vink, Marteen (2003): ”What is Europeanisation?”, European Political Science, Vol. 3, No. 1: 63 – 74.
Warleigh, Alex (2001): “Managing Difference in the European Union: Towards The Europeanisation of Civil Society?”, Civic No. 3.
Williams, Margit Besseney (2001): “Exporting the Democratic Deficit, Hungary’s Experience with EU Integration”, Problems of Post-Communism, Vol. 48, No. 1: 27-38.



Copyright (c) 2004 Søren Riishøj

Creative Commons License
Tato práce je licencována pod licencí Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.