Acts on Parliamentary Rules of Procedure and Constitutional Review of the Acts (Austria and Czech Republic)

Vol.24,No.3(2016)

Jindřiška Syllová

https://doi.org/10.5817/CPVP2016-3-8

PDF (Czech)
Abstract
Parliamentary rules of procedure and standing orders are special sets of rules. Their compliance is not reviewable by any conventional control mechanism. In addition, the behaviour of the MPs is protected by the immunity regulation. If parliamentary rules of procedure are regulated by the form of the rigid legislative act, as in the Czech Republic and in Austria, there is very difficult to amend them. In both countries the rules of procedure are reviewed by the constitutional courts. In Austria the decision of the Constitutional Court is based on the simple principle of correct expression of the will of lawmakers. The Czech Constitutional Court has accepted more complicated attitude that allows to use the test of proportionality.

Keywords:
Rules of Procedure; National Council of Austria; Constitutional Review of the Parliament Activity; History of Standing Orders; Close Relationship of Amendment

Pages:
439–450
Author biography

Jindřiška Syllová

Faculty of Law, Charles University, Prague

Faculty of Law, Charles University, Prague
References

ACHTENBERG, Norbert. Parlamentsrecht. Tübingen: Mohr, 1984. ISBN 103166447695.

AURACHER-JÄGER, Barbara. Die Mechanismen im Natinalrat. Wien: Verlag Österreich, Juristische Schriftenreihe, 1997. ISBN 3-7046-1066-6.

FILIP, J. Vliv Ústavního soudu a obecných soudů na tvorbu práva v ČR. In: GERLOCH, A., KYSELA, J. (eds.). Tvorba práva v České republice po vstupu do Evropské unie. Praha: ASPI, 2007.

KELSEN, Hans. Die Verfassungsgesetze der Republik Österreich. Wien: Franz Deuticke, 1922.

KYSELA, Jan. Vliv Ústavního soudu na pravidla zákonodárného procesu. Správní právo, 2013, č. 2.

LIENBACHER, Georg, GRZESZICK, Bernd. Rationalitätanforderungen an die parlamentarische Rechtsetzung im demokratischen Rechtsstaat, VVDStRL, Walter de Gruyter, 71/2012.

MAYER, Heinz, KUCZKO-STADLMAYER, Gabriele, STÖGER, Karl. Grundriss des österreichischen bundesverfassungsrechts. Wien: Manz’sche Verlags- und Universitätsbuchhandlung, 2015.

SCHAMBECK, Herbert. Österreichs Parlamentarismus. Berlin: Duncker und Humblot, 1988, 906 s, ISBN 3-428-06098-9.

SLÁDEČEK, Vladimír, MIKULE, Vladimír, SUCHÁNEK, Radovan, SYLLOVÁ, Jindřiška. Ústava České republiky, komentář. Praha: C. H. Beck, 2016. ISBN 978-80-7400-590-9.

WINTR, J. Tečka za nálezy o organizaci soudnictví a o legislativním procesu? Jurisprudence, č. 8/2010.

Metrics

0

Crossref logo

0

425

Views

272

PDF (Czech) views

Copyright © 2016 Jindřiška Syllová

PDF (Czech)