The EU Member States’ Right to Electricity Mix



Electricity grids between EU Member States are interconnected and therefore, electricity policy in one Member State may influence the functioning of electricity systems in the other states. This article analyzes the impact of an EU Member State’s energy policy on the other Member States from the perspective of the right to determinate their electricity mix. The paper argues that the scope of a Member State’s right to electricity mix guaranteed by Article 194(2) TFEUis limited considerably. The right of a Member State to decide on the choice of its energy sources and the general structure of its energy supply in the electricity sector is bordered by the same rights of the other Member States.

Electricity, Internal Market, Right to Energy Mix, State Sovereignty

[1] Andoura, S., Hancher, L., Woude, M. 2010, 'Policy Proposal' by Jacques Delors, Towards a European Energy Community: A Policy Proposal', Available at: <
hancher-vanderwoude-ne-march10.pdf?pdf=ok> accessed 5 April 2016

[2] Calliess, Ch., Hey, Ch. 2013, 'Multilevel Energy Policy in the EU: Paving the Way for Renewables?', European Journal for Environmental & Planning Law, vol. 10, no. 2.">

[3] Cano, G. J. 1983, 'Legislative Study No. 9. A Legal and Institutional Framework for Natural Resources Management', Available at: <> accessed 5 April 2016

[4] 2015, 'Rakousko hrozí žalobou, pokud dostane české jádro státní podporu', Available at: < pokud-dostane-ceske-jadro-statni-podporu> accessed 5 April 2016

[5] Chalmers, D., Davies, G., Monti, G. 2010, European Union Law: Cases and Materials, 2nd edn, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

[6] ClientEarth. 2010, 'The Impact of the Lisbon Treaty on Climate and Energy Policy – an Environmental Perspective'. Available at: <
on-climate-and-energy-policy.pdf> accessed 5 April 2016

[7] Currie, J. H. and others. 2014, International Law: Doctrine, Practice and the Theory, 2nd edn, Irwin Law, Toronto

[8] Czeberkus, M. A. 2013, 'Renewable Energy Sources: EU Policy and Law in Light of Integration', LL.M. thesis, University of Iceland

[9] Declaration on Rights and Duties of States, UN General Assembly Res 375 (IV) (reprinted in UN GAOR 4th Sess 66-67) UN Doc A/1251 (1949)

[10] Department of Energy & Climate Change. 2014, 'Energy – Review of the Balance of Competences: Legal Annex to the Energy Review' Available at: <
data/file/330481/Legal_Annex_BOC.pdf> accessed 5 April 2016, p. 5

[11] Directive 2009/28/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 April 2009 on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources and amending and subsequently repealing Directives 2001/77/EC and 2003/30/EC [2009] OJ L 140/16

[12] Directive 2009/72/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 July 2009 concerning common rules for the internal market in electricity and repealing Directive 2003/54/EC [2009] OJ L 211/55

[13] 2015, 'Regulátori z V4 podporujú predaj elektriny z OZE za trhové ceny', Available at: <
ceny/17176/> accessed 5 April 2016

[14] European Commission. 2010, 'Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: Energy 2020, A strategy for competitive, sustainable and secure energy COM (2010) 639 final

[15] European Commission. 2015, 'Energy Union Package, Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council, Achieving the 10% electricity interconnection target Making Europe's Electricity Grid fit for 2020', COM (2015) 82 final

[16] European Commission. 2015, 'Heating and Cooling in the European Energy Transition: Challenges and Facts', Available at: <
%20COOLING_brochure.pdf> accessed 5 April 2016

[17] Evans, M. D. 2014, International Law, 4th edn, Oxford University Press, Oxford

[18] Fouquet, D., Nysten, J. V., Johnston, A., 2012, 'Design and impact of a harmonised policy for renewable electricity in Europe: Potential areas of conflict of a harmonised RES support scheme with European Union Law (BEYOND2020)' Available at: accessed 5 April 2016

[19] Gräper, F., Schoser, Ch. 2010, 'Third Party Access' in EU Energy Law: The Internal Market, Third Liberalisation Package, 3rd edn, ed. Ch. Jones, Clayes & Casteels, place of publication not stated

[20] Gwartney, J. D., Stroup, R., Studenmund, A. H. 1980, Macroeconomics: Private and Public Choice, 2nd edn, Academic Press, London

[21] Hancher, L., Salerno, F. M. 2012, 'Energy Policy after Lisbon' in EU Law after Lisbon, eds. A. Bioni, P. Eeckhout, S. Ripley, Oxford University Press, Oxford

[22] Haraldsdóttir, K. 2014, 'The Limits of the EU Competence to Regulate Conditions for Exploitation of Energy Resources: Analysis of Article 194(2) TFEU', European Energy and Environmental Law Review, vol. 23, no. 6

[23] Hobe, S. 2015, 'Evolution of Principle on Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources' in Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources, eds. M. Bungenberg, S. Hobe, Springer, place of publication not stated

[24] Hofbauer, J. A. 2009, 'The Principle of Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources and Its Modern Implications', LL.M. thesis, University of Iceland

[25] Jayasuriya, K. 1999, 'Globalization, Law, and the Transformation of Sovereignty: The Emergence of Global Regulatory Governance', Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies, volume 6, no. 2, p. 44

[26] Johnston, A., Marel, E. 2013, 'Ad lucem? Interpreting the New EU Energy Provision, and in particular meaning of Article 194(2) TFEU', European Energy and Environmental Law Review, vol. 22, no. 5

[27] Joint Declaration on the Application of the Euratom Treaty (No 4) adopted by the plenipotentiaries of the Treaty concerning the accession of the Kingdom of Norway, the Republic of Austria, the Republic of Finland and the Kingdom of Sweden to the European Union OJ C 241, 29/08/1994

[28] Judgement C-490/10 European Parliament v Council of the European Union [2012] ECLI: EU: C: 2012: 525

[29] Judgment C-573/12 Ålands Vindkraft AB v Energimyndigheten [2014] OJ C 292/4

[30] Judgement T-370/11 Republic of Poland v Commission [2013] OJ L 114/34

[31] McEachern, W. A. 2006, Economics: A Contemporary Introduction, 7th edn, Thomson South-Western, Mason

[32] Nanda V. P., Pring, G. R. 2013, International Environmental Law and Policy for the 21st Century, 2nd rev. edn, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden

[33] Pereira, R., Gough, O. 2013, 'Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources in the 21st Century: Natural Resource Governance and the Right to Selfdetermination of Indigenous People under International Law', Melbourne Journal of International Law, volume 14, no. 2

[34] Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources, UN General Assembly Res 1803 (XVII) (14 December 14 1962) 17 UN – GAOR Supp. No 17 UN Doc. A/5217

[35] Pielow, J.-Ch., Lewendel, B. J. 2011, 'The EU Energy Policy after the Lisbon Treaty' in Financial Aspects in Energy: A European Perspective, eds. A. Dorsman and others, Springer, Heidelberg

[36] Reinhard, H. 1980, Rechtsgleichheit und Selbstbestimmung der Völker in wirtschaftlicher Hinsicht – Die Praxis der Vereinten Nationen, Springer, Berlin

[37] Schrijver, N. 1997, Sovereignty over Natural Resources: Balancing Rights and Duties, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

[38] Schulenberg, S. 2009, Die Energiepolitik der Europäischen Union, Eine kompetenzrechtliche Untersuchung unter besonderer Berücksichtigung finaler Kompetenznormen, Nomos, Baden-Baden

[39] Simm, M. 2012, 'The interface between Energy, Environment and Competition Rules of the European Union', XXV FIDE Congress, Tallinn, May/June 2012

[40] Sveen, T. 2014, 'The Interaction between Article 192 and 194 TFEU: Renewable Energy Promotion with a Predominant Environmental Purpose' in EU Renewable Energy Law: Legal Challenges and New Perspectives, ed. T. Solvang, University of Oslo, Oslo

[41] Talus, K. 2013, EU Energy Law and Policy: A Critical Account, Oxford University Press, Oxford

[42] Texaco v Libyan Arab Republic, reprinted in 17 ILM (1978) 3-37

[43] Vedder, H. 2010, 'The Treaty of Lisbon and European Environmental Law and Policy', Journal of Environmental Law, vol. 22, no. 2.">

[44] Vooren, B. 2011, 'Legal and Institutional Obstacles to an EU External EU Energy Policy post-Lisbon: Managing the Vertical and Horizontal Axes. Available at: <
2d29c9dfc867.pdf> accessed 5 April 2016

[45] Vooren, B., Wessel, R. A. 2014, EU External Relations Law: Text, Cases and Materials, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

[46] Westaway, J., Simpson, J. 2011, 'The Disintegration of the Concept of Sovereignty and the Energy Sector in the Europe' in Financial Aspects in Energy: A European Perspective, ed. A. Dorsman and others, Springer, Heidelberg